Palm Bay, Fla. — At the December 19 city council meeting, a proposed storage facility in Bayside Lakes faced fierce opposition from residents and council members, ultimately resulting in its rejection. Meanwhile, discussions about the council’s recent decision to eliminate public comments at the end of meetings raised concerns about transparency and public trust.
Bayside Lakes Storage Facility: Rejected Amid Community Concerns
Bayside Lakes, located in southeastern Palm Bay, was initially designed as a Planned Unit Development (PUD) blending residential, commercial, and recreational spaces. Approved in 1999, the plan was heralded as a transformative solution for the city’s future. However, decades later, some residents feel the development has failed to live up to its promise and are pushing back against what they see as further erosion of its original vision.
The latest controversy centers on a proposed high-quality self-storage facility that would occupy a section of Bayside Lakes previously designated for a medical office building. Developers argued that the storage facility would meet community demand and be located at the rear of the property, near a retention pond and away from residential areas. However, residents were not convinced.
“There’s a lot of commercial business potential in Bayside Lakes,” one resident said. “Could every lot eventually be turned into storage units? This isn’t what we signed up for.”
Another resident reflected on the origins of the PUD, saying, “This plan was presented in 1999 as the saving grace for the city, but that’s not what happened. They had no real plan back then—just an idea that was accepted. Let’s not repeat the mistake of not knowing what we’re agreeing to.”
Adding to the frustration, another resident stated, “You have storage facilities next to Bayside Lakes already. This is purely unacceptable.” City Planner Craig Morgan, addressing the complexities of the situation, remarked, “This has to be one of the biggest mysteries I’ve seen in 30 years.”
Despite assurances from the developer that the storage facility would be state-of-the-art and meet a pressing need, the council ultimately sided with residents, voting 5-0 to deny the proposal. Councilman Donny Hammer summed up the prevailing sentiment: “I’ve never heard anyone say, ‘We need more storage units.’”
Public Comments: Tensions Over Transparency
As frustrations over the Bayside Lakes storage facility proposal continue, residents have expressed growing concerns over the recent elimination of the second round of public comments at city council meetings.
“I’m disappointed that I’ve lost 50% of my opportunity to address you publicly,” one speaker said during a recent meeting. Pastor Mark Miller underscored the importance of the final comment period, explaining, “It was often used to offer solutions or collaborate on issues raised during the meeting.”
Council members defended the decision as a way to streamline meetings, but many residents feel it comes at the expense of transparency and community involvement. With pressing issues like the Bayside Lakes development, some question whether limiting public input risks sidelining community voices when they are needed most.
Palm Bay Explores Solutions to Homelessness as New State Law Looms
On December 17, the Palm Bay City Council held a workshop to address the city’s growing homelessness crisis, marking its first formal discussion since House Bill 1365 took effect on October 1. The law, which bans sleeping or camping on public property, is set to introduce stricter enforcement measures beginning January 1, 2025. This places pressure on cities across Florida to implement solutions for their unhoused populations while complying with the new legal framework.
During the workshop, council members explored several approaches to mitigate the issue. Discussions included the possibility of affordable housing initiatives, the expansion of emergency shelters, and providing transportation services to connect individuals to centralized support facilities. Council member Chandler Langevin expressed support for emergency shelter buses, which could help transport individuals to designated shelters outside of Palm Bay. Langevin voiced reservations about establishing a permanent shelter within city limits, citing concerns about its potential proximity to schools and family-oriented neighborhoods.
Mayor Rob Medina advocated for wraparound services, emphasizing the importance of addressing the root causes of homelessness to provide long-term solutions. The council also discussed a proposal to host a specialized event offering services and resources for homeless veterans as an initial step toward broader community support.
With the January 1 deadline fast approaching, Palm Bay’s workshop underscores the city’s intent to tackle the crisis. However, the council’s ability to turn these discussions into concrete actions will be crucial in addressing the rising number of unhoused individuals in Brevard County, which has reached its highest levels since 2016. In contrast, Broward County has implemented a more structured and well-funded response to the homelessness crisis, committing over $43 million toward affordable housing projects, shelter expansion, and eviction prevention programs.
Palm Bay, FL – The Palm Bay City Council’s recent decision to fire City Manager Suzanne Sherman has sparked significant controversy and challenges, as the council continues to navigate its search for a permanent replacement.
Last Thursday, the council voted 3-2 to terminate Sherman, who had served as City Manager since 2020. The vote, led by Councilman Chandler Langevin, was supported by Councilmembers Mike Hammer and Kenny Johnson, with Mayor Rob Medina and Councilman Mike Jaffe dissenting. Langevin defended the decision, stating that Sherman’s leadership was taking the city in the wrong direction and that “sweeping changes” were needed.
However, the firing left the council scrambling for a replacement. Department heads, including Finance Director Larry Wojciechowski and Public Works Director Valentino Perez, declined the interim role. The city’s IT Director, Brian Robinson, also resisted but was ultimately appointed as interim City Manager by a 4-1 vote, despite his protests.
During a workshop meeting on Monday, the council revisited the issue of finding long-term leadership. While Councilman Langevin proposed former City Manager Gregg Lynk for the position, his recommendation was not supported, given Lynk’s controversial past, including allegations of bribery that led to his firing in 2020.
Instead, the council turned its attention to Scott Morgan, the retired former City Manager of West Melbourne. Morgan is being considered for an interim role to help stabilize the city and assist with the recruitment of a permanent City Manager.
Council discussions reflected a focus on finding a leader who could maintain the city’s current successes while addressing critical issues like lowering the tax and millage rates.
The financial implications of Sherman’s firing remain a pressing concern. Her contract entitles her to a severance package of 20 weeks’ pay, totaling nearly $97,000, along with payouts for accrued leave. These expenses, combined with recruitment costs for a permanent replacement, could further strain the city’s budget.
As Palm Bay grapples with this leadership shake-up, residents are watching closely to see how the council handles these challenges and moves forward with its vision for the city’s future.
Stay tuned to Palm Bay Live for updates on this developing story.
PALM BAY, FLORIDA (August 23, 2024): The City of Palm Bay has released the Request for Applications for the Opioid Settlement Proceeds Grant (OSPG) for Fiscal Years 2023 and 2024. This initiative follows a historic settlement between the State of Florida and major opioid manufacturers, distributors, and dispensers, which will bring over $3 billion to Florida over the next eighteen years.
At the July 1, 2021, Regular Council Meeting, Palm Bay City Council adopted Resolution 2021-33 which recognized the harmful effects of the opioid epidemic suffered by the City. The City of Palm Bay joined the State of Florida, counties, and other cities in addressing the opioid crisis through the National Prescription Opiate Litigation. Resolution 2021-33 proposed a unified plan for the allocation and use of prospective settlement dollars from opioid-related litigation, and the City entered into a Memorandum of Understanding with the State of Florida setting the framework of the unified plan for the proposed allocation and use of opioid settlement proceeds.
In December 2023, the City received its first round of funds from the National Opioid Settlement, totaling $275,619.36. This amount includes $86,397.57 for Fiscal Year 2023 and $189,221.79 for Fiscal Year 2024. Under the terms of the agreement, a maximum of 5% ($13,780.97) may be allocated for administrative costs, leaving a balance of $261,838.39 available for grant awards.
At the July 18 Regular Council Meeting, Palm Bay City Council authorized the publication of the Request for Applications. The OSPG will support projects and initiatives that align with the three categories outlined in the Florida Opioid Allocation and Statewide Response Agreement: Treatment, Prevention, and Other Strategies. Core strategies must comply with evidence-based best practices as specified in the agreement.
Applications for the Opioid Settlement Proceeds Grant are now open. Interested parties are encouraged to review the full Request for Applications and submit their proposals in accordance with the guidelines provided. The City of Palm Bay has released Addendum 1 to the Opioid Settlement Proceeds Grant (OSPG) RFA. The in-person workshop has been postponed to Friday, August 30, 2024, at 10 am. We have extended the date for the Mandatory Technical Assistance Workshop Registration for the Opioid Settlement Proceeds Grant.
Agencies interested in applying must complete the registration form by Thursday, August 29, 2024, by 12 noon. The form located here www.pbfl.org/opioid
The workshop will be recorded and posted here www.pbfl.org/opioid for agencies not able to attend. A self-certification form, certifying the agency watched the workshop will need to be completed and submitted with the application, on September 13, 2024.”
PALM BAY, FLORIDA (August 23rd, 2024): The Palm Bay Police Department arrested Beatriz Rapisarda, a 41-year-old teacher at Sunrise Elementary School, on charges of child abuse and false imprisonment. The arrest occurred on August 22nd at the school following a detailed investigation into allegations involving a student in the intellectually disabled classroom.
The investigation revealed that Rapisarda physically pushed the student and restrained the child by grabbing their wrists. These actions were witnessed by several individuals. After a thorough review of sworn statements and evidence, sufficient probable cause was established for her arrest.
Rapisarda was taken into custody at the school and has been booked into the Brevard County Jail. The Palm Bay Police Department is committed to ensuring the safety of individuals within our community, especially our youth. We will continue to work closely with the school and our partners at the Department of Children and Families to ensure incidents such as this one are not repeated.
The Brevard County primary election results are in, setting the stage for a series of critical runoffs and general election contests in November. Several races have been decided, while others will continue to November, with significant implications for the future governance of the region.
Palm Bay Races
In Palm Bay, Mayor Rob Medina secured a second term in office, winning 54.9% of the vote and avoiding a runoff. Medina’s victory confirms the continuation of his administration, which has focused on infrastructure improvements and public safety, despite facing various challenges during his first term.
However, the Palm Bay City Council races for Seats 2 and 3 are heading to November runoffs. In the Seat 2 race, Deputy Mayor Donny Felix led with 40.2% of the vote, followed closely by Richard Mike Hammer, who received 38.4%. Patric McNally, who garnered 21.5%, has been eliminated from the race. The upcoming runoff between Felix and Hammer will determine which candidate will help shape the future of Palm Bay’s policies on growth and development.
Hammer emphasized that the success of his campaign so far is “a testament to the tireless efforts of countless supporters who shared our message of empowering residents with a voice.” He highlighted his dedication to key issues such as preventing tax increases, attracting new businesses to lower the tax burden, ensuring qualified staff, and promoting sustainable growth. “Palm Bay has faced the consequences of neglecting crucial challenges for far too long. My plan is to address these issues head-on, providing our city, its staff, and its residents with clear goals and viable options,” Hammer stated.
He also noted his positive and productive relationship with his opponent, Deputy Mayor Felix, mentioning that they have already discussed potential areas for collaboration in the lead-up to the election. “Fostering a respectful dialogue and working together, even with opposing views, is essential for the well-being of our city,” Hammer added.
The race for Seat 3, which featured a crowded field of six candidates, will also be decided in a November runoff. Chandler Langevin, who led with 27% of the vote, will face off against Alfy Ramsay Agarie, who received 21%. Langevin’s candidacy has been overshadowed by controversy, as he is currently under felony criminal investigation for allegedly misappropriating campaign funds during a previous run for state representative. The investigation, coupled with Langevin’s ties to the polarizing State Rep. Randy Fine, has made his candidacy a focal point of local political discourse. The other candidates, including Eileen Sepp, David Kearns, Peter Filiberto, and Michael Bruyette, were eliminated.
Alfy Ramsay Agarie, who emerged as a top contender for Seat 3, emphasized his priorities for Palm Bay during his campaign. “We’ve accumulated over 40,000 new residents in our city, and the infrastructure hasn’t kept up,” Agarie stated. “Right now, our infrastructure and safety are far behind where they need to be. The average response time for emergency services is 18 to 20 minutes, compared to the national average of seven to eight minutes. That’s unacceptable, and we need to focus on these priorities to make our city more comfortable and safe to live, work, and play.”
Agarie also highlighted concerns about budget management, particularly within the Public Works and Utilities departments. “These departments take a significant portion of our budget each year, but they have the capacity to generate revenue and reduce their dependence on city funds. For example, Public Works takes 27% of our budget, yet they outsource jobs that could be done in-house. By managing our budget more efficiently, we can allocate more resources to public safety, infrastructure, and other critical areas.”
Last week, in anticipation of the election results, Palm Bay City Council appointed Philip Weinberg to temporarily fill the Seat 3 vacancy left by Randy Foster, who resigned in June due to health concerns. The outcome of the November runoff will finalize the council’s composition and could significantly influence the city’s direction on key issues like public safety, infrastructure, and economic development.
Brevard County Commission District 3
In a tightly contested race for Brevard County Commission District 3, Kim Adkinson narrowly defeated John Dittmore, capturing 50.7% of the vote. Adkinson, who previously served as a Republican state committeewoman, will now face Democrat Yvonne Minus, a Melbourne City Councilwoman, in the general election. District 3, encompassing areas like West Melbourne, Palm Bay, and South Brevard County, is pivotal in shaping county policies, especially in managing growth and development.
Brevard County Commission District 5
Rep. Thad Altman secured the Republican primary for District 5 with 70.5% of the vote, defeating Ritch Workman. Altman, who previously served on the District 5 commission from 1984 to 1992 and has extensive experience in the Florida Legislature, will face Democrat Vinnie Taranto in November. Altman’s return to county-level politics was anticipated, given his extensive background, but his decisive victory over Workman, a former state representative, was significant.
Altman’s previous tenure on the commission and his legislative experience have made him a well-known figure in Brevard politics. His platform focused on maintaining the county’s growth while ensuring that public services, particularly in areas like public safety, are adequately funded. Despite his political experience, Workman’s loss highlights Altman’s strong support base within the district.
State Senate District 19
Randy Fine emerged victorious in the Republican primary for State Senate District 19, securing 73.6% of the vote against Charles “Chuck” Sheridan. Fine, a controversial figure in Florida politics, has been at the center of several high-profile disputes, including efforts to remove him from the ballot over alleged paperwork issues. Despite these challenges, Fine’s strong showing in the primary underscores his influence in the district.
Fine’s campaign was marked by his usual fiery rhetoric and a focus on issues like securing state funding for the Indian River Lagoon and advocating for conservative values. His victory sets up a November general election battle against Democrat Vance Ehrens. Sheridan, Fine’s opponent, has indicated that he may continue to challenge Fine’s eligibility in court, keeping the race in the spotlight.
Fine’s tenure in the Florida House has been marked by his aggressive approach to politics, often engaging in public spats with both opponents and allies. His involvement in local controversies, such as his efforts to disband the Brevard County School Board, has made him a polarizing figure. As he prepares for the general election, these issues are likely to continue to play a role in the campaign narrative.
U.S. House of Representatives, District 8
Former Florida Senate President Mike Haridopolos secured the Republican nomination for U.S. House District 8 with 73.9% of the vote in Brevard County and 68% in Indian River County. Haridopolos entered the race on the final day of candidate filing, the same day that incumbent Rep. Bill Posey announced his retirement and endorsed Haridopolos.
Haridopolos, a resident of Indian Harbour Beach, has been a prominent figure in Florida politics, having served as Senate President and in both the Florida House and Senate. His campaign emphasized his legislative experience and his ability to bring conservative leadership to Washington. Haridopolos’s entry into the race effectively cleared the field of high-profile competitors, leaving him to face only lesser-known opponents.
His campaign has been bolstered by endorsements from key Republican figures, including former President Donald Trump, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, and both of Florida’s U.S. Senators. Despite his strong support, Haridopolos faced criticism from his opponents, particularly John Hearton, who questioned his political background and the influence of major donors on his campaign. Haridopolos now moves on to face Democratic nominee Sandy Kennedy in November.
Florida House Districts 32 and 33
Tuesday’s primary set the stage for the November 5 general election for the Florida House of Representatives District 32 and District 33 seats, which represent Central and South Brevard.
In the District 32 race, Florida Senator Debbie Mayfield defeated former Congressman Dave Weldon, securing 65% of the vote. Mayfield, a resident of Indialantic, received significant support from the district’s Republican base, which makes up about 47% of the electorate. Mayfield’s campaign focused on conservative values, including protecting the Indian River Lagoon and maintaining Florida’s status as a “free state.” She will face Democrat Juan Jose Hinojosa in November, who was unopposed in the primary.
The District 33 race saw Monique Miller, a cybersecurity executive and Board of Directors of Moms for Liberty member, winning the Republican primary with 55% of the vote. Miller, who has received backing from prominent conservative figures, will now face Democrat Vernon Mitchell Anderson Jr. in November. Anderson, who defeated Anthony Yantz in the Democratic primary with 53% of the vote, aims to break a three-decade losing streak for Democrats in this district. Anderson’s campaign has emphasized issues like voter rights, infrastructure, and affordable housing, while Miller has focused on immigration and reducing the cost of living for Florida families.
Brevard County School Board District 3
John Thomas won the District 3 seat on the Brevard School Board, securing 56.4% of the vote against Amber Yantz. Thomas, a former Melbourne city council member and school administrator, campaigned on a platform of early childhood education, career and technical education expansion, and improving school safety. His victory marks a shift in the board’s composition, as he replaces Jennifer Jenkins, the only liberal on the board.
Thomas’s victory is significant for the conservative movement within Brevard County, as it solidifies the board’s shift to the right. Thomas has taken a strong stance on several issues, including supporting the presence of chaplains in schools and expanding the guardian program, which allows certain school employees to carry firearms. Yantz, a mother of five with a more progressive platform, was unable to overcome Thomas’s strong support base.
Brevard County School Board District 4
The race for District 4 will head to a runoff in November between Matt Susin and Avanese “Ava” Taylor. Susin led the race with 48.6% of the vote, while Taylor received 32.8%. Susin, who was first elected to the board in 2016, has maintained a conservative stance on key issues, including the expansion of the guardian program and the removal of certain books from school libraries.
Taylor, inspired to run after her son was the victim of a hazing incident, has positioned herself as a more moderate candidate. While she supports some conservative measures, such as the guardian program, she has expressed concerns about its implementation and the potential for it to create inequities in the school system. The runoff will determine whether the board will continue its conservative trajectory or shift toward a more balanced approach.
Supervisor of Elections
Tim Bobanic, the incumbent Brevard County Supervisor of Elections, won the Republican primary with 59.6% of the vote, defeating County Commissioner John Tobia. Bobanic, appointed by Governor Ron DeSantis in 2022, has faced scrutiny over his handling of election-related issues, including a recent lawsuit that sought to remove candidates from the ballot due to alleged paperwork errors.
Bobanic’s victory solidifies his position as Supervisor of Elections, as he will face only a write-in candidate in November, making his win nearly assured. Tobia, who has been embroiled in his own controversies during his time as County Commissioner, was unable to overcome Bobanic’s strong support, particularly from those who view him as a steady hand in the management of the county’s elections.
The lawsuit against Bobanic, filed by political consultant Robert Burns, accused his office of improperly accepting incomplete qualifying paperwork from candidates, including Randy Fine. Although the case was dismissed, it highlighted ongoing concerns about election integrity in Brevard County. Bobanic’s re-election will likely continue to be scrutinized as he navigates these challenges in the lead-up to the general election.
This article is the last installment of a four-part series of charter schools by Palm Bay Live.
Charter Schools in Brevard County: Funding and Oversight
According to Russell Bruhn, Chief Strategic Communications Officer for Brevard Public Schools, charter schools in Brevard County are financed through a combination of state, local, and federal funds, similar to other public schools. The primary source of funding is the Florida Education Finance Program (FEFP), which allocates funds based on the number of full-time enrolled students. Additionally, charter schools have the opportunity to enhance their funding through federal grants. One notable example is the Charter School Program Grant, which supports the planning and initial implementation of charter schools.
“Each charter school has a unique blend of federal, state, and local funding, depending on the specific grants they are able to secure and the number of students they serve,” explained Bruhn.
In terms of oversight, Brevard County maintains rigorous accountability measures to ensure that charter schools meet both financial and academic standards. “All charter schools in the district are required to submit monthly or quarterly financial reports, depending on whether they have achieved high-performing status,” Bruhn stated. Moreover, the district actively monitors these schools to ensure they comply with state statutes covering all aspects of their operations.
Financial transparency is critical in the oversight process. Charter schools must submit an annual audit to the district, which is then made available to the public on each school’s website. This process ensures that stakeholders, including parents and community members, have access to detailed financial information about the schools.
Billy Prasad, Deputy Director of Brevard County Planning and Development, elaborates on the zoning and land development aspects of charter schools. “From a zoning standpoint, charter schools are treated similarly to other public schools, with certain exceptions. For example, specific provisions in our Code of Ordinances allow the Board of County Commissioners to direct educational facility impact fees toward the construction of charter school facilities,” Prasad notes. Additionally, the Public School Facilities Element of the Comprehensive Plan includes policies that facilitate the use of charter schools as mitigation options to address school capacity issues.
Over the past decade, two charter schools in Brevard County have closed due to financial instability and insufficient academic performance. “When a charter school closes, any remaining public funds, as well as property and equipment purchased with those funds, are returned to the district school board,” Bruhn clarified. This policy helps safeguard public investments and ensures that resources are redistributed to other public schools within the district.
The location of charter schools is also regulated to ensure they meet community needs and educational standards. Prospective charter schools must apply through a state-mandated process, which includes a thorough review of their proposed location as part of a comprehensive assessment by the district. “The review process is designed to evaluate how well the proposed site will serve the community and support the school’s educational goals,” said Bruhn.
Management and Locations of Charter Schools in Brevard County
In the world of charter schools, management fees are a common expense. These fees are often paid to organizations that handle administrative, curriculum development, and operational tasks for the schools. They can vary widely depending on the size of the school, the scope of services provided, and the specific contractual agreements in place.
For instance, in Brevard County, the disparity in management fees among different charter schools is quite noticeable. According to 2021 IRS Form 990 submissions, Palm Bay Academy reported management fees of $29,567. In contrast, Odyssey Charter School paid significantly higher fees amounting to nearly $1.7 million. Meanwhile, Emma Jewel Charter School incurred $93,000 in management fees. These figures highlight the varying scale and administrative needs of each school.
The implications of such management fees are multifaceted. While these fees support the operational efficiency of charter schools, they also raise questions about financial priorities and the allocation of public education funds. High management fees, as seen with Odyssey, suggest a substantial investment in specialized services, which could indicate a focus on enhancing educational quality or administrative depth. However, it also prompts scrutiny regarding the cost-effectiveness of outsourcing school management functions and the impact on budget allocations for direct educational activities.
In Brevard County, the guidelines regarding the placement of charter schools are notably flexible, emphasizing the adaptability of educational services to community needs. Dr. Melinda Maier, Director of Curriculum & Instruction at Brevard Public Schools, shared insights into the process. “As far as the charter office is concerned, there are no regulations that impact the location of charter schools within the county,” Dr. Maier explained. She noted that applicants for new charter schools may not specify a location initially. “When a potential charter school applies, they may not even know the location at which they would be housed,” she added.
If an applying charter has a proposed location, the county considers the strategic need for a school in that area. Dr. Maier emphasized the focus on community requirements: “If they do have a location, we do take into account if the area is in need of a charter school.”
Brevard County Charter Schools Controversies
Charter schools are mandated to employ certified teachers, in accordance with statutory requirements. Teachers working in or contracted by charter schools must hold the appropriate certifications as stipulated by current legislation. Recently, however, controversies have come to light regarding charter school personnel. Not only was a new principal, previously arrested in 2010 for stealing prescription drugs from teachers, selected for leadership, but also a teacher arrested in January 2023 for domestic violence was named “Teacher of the Year.” Furthermore, the only assistant principal who was set to return for this school year at Odyssey Charter Jr/Sr High was placed on probation last year for his previous actions of violently restraining students by using his forearm across their throats during his tenure at Palm Bay High.
These incidents not only raise questions about the vetting and selection process for staff within charter schools but also about the standards for advancing individuals to leadership positions. Odyssey Charter seems to be a haven for individuals with criminal histories, academic shortcomings, and various professional reprimands, often advancing them to higher roles. This pattern of behavior raises concerns not just about the qualifications of the staff but also about the financial priorities of the school. Notably, in 2021, Odyssey Charter reported spending over $1.6 million in management and $91,000 in legal fees, as detailed in their IRS Form 990.
According to the Brevard Public Schools senior communications coordinator, there are 15 charter schools in Brevard County, 6 of which are located in Palm Bay. Despite Brevard Public Schools maintaining a “B” rating in the latest report card issued by the Florida Department of Education, an analysis of school performance reveals a noteworthy disparity in excellence. While only Education Horizons Charter School achieved an “A” rating, 21 public elementary schools, including Pinewood, Atlantis, and South Lake, secured top marks.
Brevard County Charter Schools and Public Opinion
To gauge public opinion more directly, Palm Bay Live conducted a Facebook poll that garnered responses from 592 participants. Thirty-four percent expressed a preference for charter schools, below the 51% who favored public schools. Additionally, alternative options also had their share of support: 4% chose ‘none of the above,’ 2% leaned towards parochial schools, and 9% preferred homeschooling.
Commenters voiced their reasons for their choices, touching on a variety of critical issues. One prevalent theme was concern over the long-term impacts of shifting public funds to charter, private, and religious schools. This reallocation, some argued, has contributed to the dwindling quality of public education, a trend exacerbated by political decisions favoring charter schools over traditional public ones. One community member noted, “That is what is wrong with charter schools—they take from the public schools’ funds.”
Other community members voiced frustration over what they perceive as more lenient regulations governing charter schools, particularly regarding student discipline. For example, a local remarked on charter schools’ ability to expel students for misconduct, adding, “Public schools aren’t given that luxury.”
Yet, others argued for the benefits of parental choice and the tailored educational approaches that charter schools can offer, suggesting that for some students, these institutions provide a better fit than their public counterparts. One community member stated, “Personally, it’s about parental choice [and] the best school that meets the needs of the student.”
Moreover, commenters debated the accountability and oversight of charter schools, with some pointing out the lack of stringent standards that public schools are subject to. This raised alarms about the potential for fiscal mismanagement and educational inconsistency within the charter system. Yet, others argued for the benefits of parental choice and the tailored educational approaches that charter schools can offer, suggesting that for some students, these institutions provide a better fit than their public counterparts.
Echoing through the comments was a call for a balanced perspective on school choice, recognizing the value in both charter and public schools while advocating for reforms that ensure quality education across the board. The conversation also touched on the comparative performance of charter versus public schools in Brevard County, citing statistics to support various viewpoints on which system offers superior education.
The qualifying period for Palm Bay’s upcoming elections in August and November ended on Friday, June 14th. Included in this article are Financial Disclosures (FORM 6) Filed by 10 Candidates.
In a related development, a federal judge recently blocked a 2023 Florida law that required municipal elected officials to disclose detailed financial information. The ruling came after numerous officials, including 10 out of the 19 Palm Bay candidates, filed the required Form 6 disclosures. The law was challenged for potentially violating First Amendment rights, and the judge sided with municipal officials, issuing a preliminary injunction just weeks before the filing deadline. According to the City Clerk’s office, the list of candidates for Palm Bay City Council has been finalized for the upcoming primary election on August 20, 2024, and the special election in November for Seat 5. Amidst much anticipation, the roster has been solidified, with Randy Foster (Seat 3) and Nathan Timothy White (Seat 5) notably absent from the list of qualified candidates.
Councilman Foster, who made headlines in 2020 by securing a record-breaking 33,858 votes, recently returned to his council duties following a severe health scare. Foster was hospitalized in early March and fell into a diabetic coma, which led to his frequent absence from council meetings. Despite his recovery and return to duties, Foster did not file to qualify for the upcoming election, marking a significant development in the race.
Nathan White, a lifelong Palm Bay resident, had planned to run for City Council Seat 5 but also did not file to qualify for the election. White previously ran for City Council Seat 4 in 2022.
The candidates vying for Seat 3 include Alfy Ramsay Agarie, Michael J. Bruyette, Peter J. Filiberto, David Anthony Kearns, Chandler Langevin, and Eileen Sepp. Alfy Ramsay Agarie is a new addition to the list. He has previously run for public office, including a bid for mayor, but has not held a seat on the City Council.
With Foster out of the race, the dynamics of the election for Seat 3 could shift significantly. The residents of Palm Bay will be watching closely as the candidates campaign in the lead-up to the primary election on August 20, 2024.
In addition to the Seat 3 candidates, the City Clerk’s office has confirmed the following candidates for other offices:
Office of Mayor:
Rob Medina – qualified June 10, 2024
Edith M. Rivera – qualified June 12, 2024
Tatiana Rosado – qualified June 13, 2024
Santa Isabel Wright – qualified June 12, 2024
City Council Seat 2:
Donny J. Felix – qualified June 10, 2024
Richard ‘Mike’ Hammer – qualified June 12, 2024
Patric McNally – qualified June 12, 2024
Special Election – City Council Seat 5 (November 5, 2024):
Brevard County, FL- This morning, the Brevard Public School Board voted in favor of the expansion of our Sheriff Training On Site Marshall Program (S.T.O.M.P.) to include district personnel who meet specific qualifications to serve as Guardians. Safety is Brevard Public Schools (BPS) number one priority for all students and staff, and the inclusion of Guardians to supplement our School Resource Officers and School Security Specialists, will further support our mission to serve every student with excellence as the standard.
The expansion allows employees the opportunity to apply to be a school-based guardian. The program is voluntary and only employees who are not assigned to a classroom, and as outlined in the terms of their Brevard Federation of Teacher bargaining contract, may volunteer and/or qualify.
All employee volunteers who qualify for, and are accepted into, the S.T.O.M.P. program will undergo employment vetting, and must successfully complete the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office S.T.O.M.P training requirements before completion. Employee volunteers who advance, will have no law enforcement authority in any capacity, except in the extent necessary to prevent or stop an active assailant incident at any Brevard Public School’s site.
BPS Superintendent Dr. Mark Rendell noted: “This is an additional layer of security for our schools. While this program is new to Brevard, it is not new to Florida as numerous other districts have had Guardians in schools for several years. The individuals who will be in the program are not classroom teachers or other positions that are part of the instructional staff covered by the teacher contract. All Guardians will have to go through the same screening process and intensive training that is required by our School Safety Specialists. I am thankful that we have employees who are willing to volunteer to serve in these positions. I am also grateful for the strong partnership we have the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office which provides such rigorous training.”
S.T.O.M.P. was formed by the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office (BCSO), in partnership with Brevard Schools, following the tragic events which occurred at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School on February 14, 2018. In accordance with the 2018 Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act (Florida Senate Bill 7026), S.T.O.M.P. was developed and has served as our program which oversees all School Resource Officers and Security Specialists within Brevard Public Schools sites.
Training is currently slated to begin July 2024, through collaboration with the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office.
For requests regarding further information on S.T.O.M.P. training, please contact the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office. For media inquiries or further information regarding BPS’ role in S.T.O.M.P., please contact: [Ryan Dufrain] [Assistant Superintendent to Human Resources] [321-633-1000 ext. 11200] [dufrain.ryan@brevardschools.org]
The Rise of For-Profit Management in Florida’s Charter Schools
In Florida, the line between non-profit charter schools and for-profit management is increasingly blurred. Although charter schools are required to operate as non-profits, many engage for-profit firms to manage their operations. These companies profit by collecting management fees and through leasing arrangements for school facilities. Often, the management firm itself or a related real estate entity owns the property, effectively making the school’s management company its landlord as well. These financial arrangements are funded by the per-student allocations provided by state legislation, with some schools paying over $1 million annually in lease payments alone, as highlighted by the nonprofit research institute Integrity Florida.
Carol Burris, Executive Director of the Network for Public Education, notes that about half of all Florida charter schools are operated by for-profit organizations. Notable entities like Academica and Charter Schools USA, which originate from Florida, dominate the charter landscape, raising concerns about the influence of profit motives on educational quality. Moreover, smaller for-profit chains, managing fewer than 10 schools, are also prevalent in the state.
Reports and investigations have revealed instances where for-profit management companies exert substantial control over charter schools’ day-to-day operations, sometimes funneling a significant portion of the schools’ revenue into fees or lease payments to related entities.
A February 2020 report by the LeRoy Collins Institute further reveals that over 40% of Florida’s charter schools are run by for-profit Education Management Organizations (EMOs), a rate much higher than the national average.
The prevalence of for-profit Education Management Organizations (EMOs) in Florida, particularly notable in Miami-Dade County, where such entities manage 77% of charter schools as of 2020, adds a complex layer to the ongoing debate about the allocation of public education funds. Critics are concerned about the transparency and accountability of public funds, especially given instances where state education dollars might benefit the for-profit entities more directly than the students.
Burris also notes the involvement of real estate developers in the charter school sector is particularly noteworthy. For instance, Academica, founded and still owned by real estate developers, exemplifies this trend. Burris highlights an intriguing case involving The Villages, where a charter school exclusive to its employees ensures their continued employment. Additionally, the establishment of the Ina A. Cohen Charter School, financed by a family foundation linked to the community’s builders, raises questions about financial entanglements and interests.
Finally, Burris underscores the concerning trend of Florida’s inadequate funding for public schools, as highlighted by the Education Law Center. “Florida does a terrible job funding its public schools by all their research standards,” Barris states. “By starving its public schools, the Florida legislature is driving families into charter schools, leaving the neediest students as well as those with serious learning disabilities behind in the underfunded public schools.”
Charter School Closures and Financial Instability
As of May 10, at least 491 charter schools have closed in Florida since 1998, including 15 in Brevard County. These closures hint at underlying challenges within the charter school system, sparking concerns about their long-term viability and the oversight mechanisms in place to safeguard educational standards and public investment. They also mean that taxpayer funds, once allocated to these privately owned entities for educational purposes, cannot be recouped.
The Florida Auditor General’s latest report for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2022, uncovers several pressing issues within the charter school sector, casting a spotlight on the financial instability that plagues some of these institutions. An analysis of 688 schools revealed that 47 were grappling with significant financial issues, and 15 were dire enough to raise serious alarms. Perhaps more concerning is the pattern of repeated mistakes, indicating a systemic failure to address and rectify ongoing financial mismanagement.
Additionally, the report highlighted that 51 charter schools operated at a loss during that fiscal year. Four schools’ viability was under question due to financial troubles. A critical issue identified in the report was a lack of transparency. Some schools failed to adequately disclose important financial information, such as budgets and spending reports.
The State of Florida has recently announced plans to strengthen charter school oversight. The Department of Education announced plans to develop a rule to implement charter school oversight measures approved over the last two years. This initiative aims to address the financial instability and lack of transparency identified in the Auditor General’s report. The proposed rule will focus on charter school sponsors, ensuring they oversee the schools’ finances effectively and uphold participation in a state accountability system. A “standard monitoring tool” is in the works to facilitate annual site reviews of charter schools.
Influence of Lobbying and Contributions on Education Policy
According to a 2018 report by Integrity Florida, the charter school industry has played a significant role in shaping education policy through lobbying efforts and political contributions. From 1998 to 2016, the industry spent over $13 million on influencing state education policy, with the aim of legislating changes to expand and financially support charter schools.
One of the most telling instances of this influence was the passage of House Bill 7069 in 2017, which helped expand charter schools by easing the process of opening new schools and mandating revenue sharing from traditional public schools to charter schools for capital projects.
Governor DeSantis’s recent signing of HB 1285 also simplifies the process of converting underperforming public schools into charter schools. This law mandates that any public school receiving consecutive low-performance evaluations be designated as a “turnaround school.” If school districts fail to improve these schools, they are required to contract with a charter school operator by October 1 of the final year of control.
HB 1285 also streamlines the negotiation process between school districts and charter school operators. Key provisions ensure that new charter schools give enrollment preference to students from the previous school’s zone and operate at the same grade levels as the public school they replace. These charter schools are also exempt from paying rent for the facility, and school districts are prohibited from imposing administrative fees.
Financial records from Transparency USA highlight the scale of contributions by prominent industry players. Charter Schools USA, for instance, contributed over $1.4 million across the past three election cycles in the Sunshine State. The Florida Department of State Division of Elections records also reveal specific contributions to key members of the Senate Committee on Education Pre-K-12. In 2022, Charter Schools USA made strategic donations of $1,000 each to three committee members: Senator Corey Simon, Representative Alexis Maria Calatayud, and Representative Jay Collins, all part of the Republican Party and influential in educational legislative matters.
The Florida Federation for Children also plays a critical dual role through its PAC and ECO. The PAC focuses on direct political contributions and campaigning, with over $1.3 million in contributions and $1.4 million in expenditures in 2020, and more than $1.9 million contributed with around $1.7 million spent in 2022. In contrast, the ECO, which focuses on broader election communication efforts, spent about $715,000 in 2018 and $28,000 in 2020. Charter Schools USA has been a notable donor to the PAC, contributing more than $350,000 in 2020 and about $375,000 in 2022.
This article is the second installment of an investigative series on charter schools by Palm Bay Live. Stay tuned for subsequent parts, where we will delve deeper into the intricacies and impact of charter schools in Florida’s education system.
Governor DeSantis approved House Bill 1259 last year, which updated how charter schools receive capital outlay funds. This legislation allows for a reduction of funds previously allocated to traditional public schools’ capital expenditures, to now support charter schools. It sets out a phase-out of existing funding restrictions, allowing charter schools to access revenues from the discretionary 1.5 millage local tax. Charter schools must also commit to returning any publicly funded assets to the district in the event of closure.
Proponents argue that the law is a step toward ensuring that charter school students are not disadvantaged in terms of capital outlay funding, which has historically been lower per student compared to traditional public schools. They claim that this approach recognizes the evolving role of charter schools and ensures that funding is student-centered, following students to their chosen public educational institutions. Critics, however, say this shift may impose financial burdens on public school districts. They highlight the risk of diverting essential funds from schools that have longstanding public accountability and infrastructure requirements.
The law is part of a broader legislative effort, including other educational initiatives like HB 891, which pilots year-round schooling in five districts in the 2024-25 school year. This initiative aims to address learning loss and juvenile crime rates that rise with summer temperatures.
Charter Schools and the Battle Over Public Dollars
Funding for Florida’s charter schools, particularly through property taxes, has been a significant area of contention. A 2023 proposal that sparked debate would have required school districts to share local property-tax revenue with charter schools based on the schools’ proportionate share of total school district enrollment.
Charter schools have recently won significant funding battles. In one instance, a court ruled that charter schools in Palm Beach County are entitled to a cut of tax dollars from a property-tax increase approved by voters, which was initially intended for traditional public school safety and teacher pay improvements. In 2022, another appeals court ruled that charter schools are entitled to receive a share of property-tax money approved by voters.
Recently, the conversation around the allocation of these funds took a more contentious turn in Broward County. At the heart of this latest dispute is Manny Diaz, Jr., Florida’s Education Commissioner, who has been a prominent advocate for charter schools. During his tenure as a state lawmaker, Diaz was instrumental in shaping policies that have made Florida a fertile ground for charter school expansion, partly through significant campaign contributions from the school choice sector.
This advocacy has continued into his role as Education Commissioner, where he is now ensuring that charter schools receive millions in public funds — funds initially set aside for traditional public schools in Broward County. The crux of the matter dates back to a tax referendum approved by Broward voters in 2018, aimed at raising funds for school safety and teacher pay improvements. Legal and legislative changes since then have mandated that these funds be shared with charter schools, a move that has led to lawsuits from charter schools demanding their share.
State officials have taken a firm stance on the issue, asserting that Broward County Public Schools (BCPS) owes around $80 million to charter schools in the district. This claim has led to heightened tensions and legal battles, with BCPS arguing that such a payout could severely impact its budget. The state’s response has been unequivocal, with Diaz and the State Board of Education demanding compliance and threatening sanctions for non-compliance, underscoring the ongoing tug-of-war over public education funding in Florida.
Amid these financial disputes, BCPS is facing significant challenges due to a years-long loss in enrollment, with a decrease of 57,857 students since the 2004/05 school year. During the same period, charter school enrollments have seen a corresponding increase of 26,559 students. This decline has escalated financial pressures, leading to the “Redefining Our Schools” initiative aimed at addressing the issue of under-enrollment and inefficiencies across the district. Under the proposed plans, BCPS has presented a drastic step of closing three schools: Olsen Middle in Dania Beach, Oakridge Elementary in Hollywood, and Broward Estates Elementary in Lauderhill. Additionally, plans for grade reconfiguration at Pines Middle, Hollywood Central Elementary, and Sunland Park Academy, as well as public-private partnerships for Quiet Waters Elementary, Deerfield Beach Elementary, and Tedder Elementary, have been laid out as part of the district’s restructuring efforts.
In a significant shift in education funding, Governor Ron DeSantis signed House Bill 1 into law in 2023, dramatically expanding access to school vouchers across Florida. This legislation broadened school voucher access, which can impact the funding landscape for both charter and traditional public schools. By removing income and enrollment limitations, the bill extended voucher eligibility to nearly all Florida families, stirring concerns over the redirection of funds traditionally allocated to public schools.
The expanded school voucher program in Florida, as of 2023, allows all K-12 students to be eligible for private school scholarships, averaging around $7,700. This can cover tuition and other educational expenses like private tutoring. There’s also a provision for homeschooled students, limited to 20,000 this school year. Additionally, there’s a $750 transportation scholarship for public school students attending schools outside their neighborhood.